- Credits
- 0
The second: if orders reach to XXX lot size, then stop orders..but not every order, just the ones that require a lot that is above the XXX value..do you think that would be possible to code it that way?
Suggestion I will make a Free EA with your Indicator
- Thread starter winidecorw
- Start date
The second: if orders reach to XXX lot size, then stop orders..but not every order, just the ones that require a lot that is above the XXX value..do you think that would be possible to code it that way?
- Credits
- 0
- Credits
- 11
What about this? if you set max lot size =0.9LOT (for example)
BUY 0.1LOT
SELL 0.2LOT
BUY 0.1LOT
SELL 0.5LOT
----------------------
Total 0.9LOT
If your total order lot size is 0.9LOTs, stop new orders, so you can minimize lot size increase and risk.
Backtest is working, right?
For me it is working fine.
Attachments
Hi Tanaka,
I have tested 50K starting balance Trio EA (EU pair) with start lot 0.01 and it didn't survive . The EA is good to some point but the main problem I see is that all 3 engines are trading on the same time frame. It might be much better if each engine TF could have different inputs...for example one would be traded on M15, the other on H1 and the third on H4. Because all 3 indys EA is using give too similar values on the same TF, but they would start trading at very different points in time if CCI would give M15 value, Stoch H1 value and RSI H4 value. Maybe worth thinking about it....
Green pips to you and thank you for your excellent work
Attachments
Sorry mr tanaka akiko i i just want to upgrade th EA that you already made i didnt mean to send private requests
- Credits
- 0
I don't know why, but backtest of this EA doesn't work on my usual MT4
I just tested it in another MT4 and it works fine, I guess the other MT4 was too old
About your idea for the MaxLots parameter: sounds GREAT to me
About the post of Rocky16..it seems that this Trio Orchestra version is exactly the same as the famous AF Global, which I don't have the mql4 file..
Trio Orchestra is better than Ilan TrioKS in backtest, which is not identical to AF Global..
I'm testing Trio Orchestra on a real account, and I'm quite sure that with the correct initial lot, the right max amount of positions and the max number of lots it will survive almost any market condition on EURUSD..that's why I'm asking you these adjustments
Last edited:
I don't know why, but backtest doesn't work on my MT4
About your idea for the MaxLots parameter: sounds GREAT to me
About the post of Rocky16..it seems that this Trio Orchestra version is exactly the same as the famous AF Global, which I don't have the mql4 file..
Trio Orchestra is better than Ilan TrioKS in backtest, which is not identical to AF Global..
I'm testing Trio Orchestra on a real account, and I'm quite sure that with the correct initial lot, the right max amount of positions and the max number of lots it will survive almost any market condition on EURUSD..that's why I'm asking you these adjustments
I tested 50K with 0.01 starting lot! The profits per year were 10K and in second year DD was 50K. Sure it can survive with 100K maybe but profits would be 10% per year and DD still 5 times bigger. Good profitable consistent EA should have more average yearly gain then max DD in 10 years. Maybe you do not understand that but think about it. If you use 50% equity stop on 100K account it will take you 5 years to recover from that loss!!!! If you use 5% equity stop it can be hit more then once per year if it is bad year and the result is also bad. I'm sure you do understand that not all EAs that can survive are good . If they don't bring profits they are not good. ( the numbers above were examples but the max DD and profits per year ratio is real and bad on this EA)
- Credits
- 0
If you tested it with the base pipstep value, your backtest is useless..try to triplicate that value, in AF Global it's set on 180 instead of 50.....9/10 max positions per strategy..you'll see the difference
Also..backtest is a thing, forward test on a real account is another one 
Bro, I used 20 pips (200 points step) . Say you for example limit trades to 5. The only thing you do with this is limit blowup, but the loss can still grow and it takes forever to get out. The EA as is is not good, even if Tanaka manages max lot it will help locking in part of DD but if trend persists you cannot get out of the trade ever and you will have to take a loss that will take a long time to recover.If you tested it with the base pipstep value, your backtest is useless..try to triplicate that value, in AF Global it's set on 180 instead of 50.....9/10 max positions per strategy..you'll see the difference
But, test it yourself with quick candles test 2014 until today and you will definitly stop trading it on real account.
- Credits
- 0
5 trades is definitely not enough for this kind of EA..anyway, there's no need to discuss about this..let's Tanaka finish his job..thank you for the advice anyway, for me every opinion is always welcome!
P.S.: anyway, if you have some safe and sustainable strategy to share, I'm all ears!
Last edited:
EA win rate 90% looks promissing, but too early to say, needs much more long term testing..maybe even some new adjustments. I posted 2.5 years tick test result and set yesterday..you can play with it and see if you can improve it.5 trades is definitely not enough for this kind of EA..anyway, there's no need to discuss about this..let's Tanaka finish his job..thank you for the advice anyway, for me every opinion is always welcome!
P.S.: anyway, if you have some safe and sustainable strategy to share, I'm all ears!
- Credits
- 0
Hi, I agree with you. I didn't sleep much last night and made a lot of simulation with superarrow & one another EA from this forum. I found that made long backtests is waste of time. You can try only some periods with big trend to find if EA is stable. There is several those periods last few years. All of this EAs completely failed in those periods of time. No way without stop losses.
Mr tanaka akiko th EA(EA_rsi ma mtf alerts arrows d1(revA)) you made it very powerful but it open trades without known the trend direction take a look at picture 1 and 3
and take a look at the picture number 2 and 4 after puting shady 2019 indicator hi will know when to open buy and when to open sell .some time shady 2019 indicator gives fast signal one sell and after 15 min buy the EA have pen sell then it have change to open buy with multiple lot like he does always .so the same indicater just use shady2019 indicator like filter to know when to open buy trade or sell trade i think that will make him a very powerful EXPERT ADVISOR once again i m sorry and thank you for your great help
Attachments
One more profitable set file- it is not drop dead profitable but last 4 years no blowup and it is a start. Guys, if you want results test like crazy and share here otherwise we will be stuck! Try to improve my set file- same DD bigger profits. But first task is limiting DD once this is managed then profits can have full attention.
Attachments
Many fail, not all this is a difference. It is just that Ronaldo's set file is doomed to fail sooner or later. With bad luck it can happen next week.
But, this doesn't mean one or 2 days of testing is enough. There are many pairs, time frames and inputs to test on many EAs ( thanks to Tanaka) and you have your whole life ahead of you to search for a good enough EA and set file. Might take you months of testing but even every small improvement in results count. You can forget getting rich quick in forex, it is a business.
If Tanaka would give up after 2 days like you are suggesting he would not be here and you would have nothing to test. So take him as a role model!
Mr tanaka akiko th EA(EA_rsi ma mtf alerts arrows d1(revA)) you made it very powerful but it open trades without known the trend direction take a look at picture 1 and 3
and take a look at the picture number 2 and 4 after puting shady 2019 indicator hi will know when to open buy and when to open sell .some time shady 2019 indicator gives fast signal one sell and after 15 min buy the EA have pen sell then it have change to open buy with multiple lot like he does always .so the same indicater just use shady2019 indicator like filter to know when to open buy trade or sell trade i think that will make him a very powerful EXPERT ADVISOR once again i m sorry and thank you for your great help
the same ...
P.S.
excellent result in BT but ...
(alpha constant in the growth as the hypothenuse of the right triangle)
... orders in FT not all closed
(those left to their ... fate ...)
Last edited:
- Credits
- 0
Tanaka martin attack fix...
for example if martin attack is true...
Attack martin pipstep 2 and manual profit 0 and main stoploss 10
- Credits
- 11
I think I can try MaxLots parameter. Give me some time.I don't know why, but backtest of this EA doesn't work on my usual MT4
I just tested it in another MT4 and it works fine, I guess the other MT4 was too old
About your idea for the MaxLots parameter: sounds GREAT to me
About the post of Rocky16..it seems that this Trio Orchestra version is exactly the same as the famous AF Global, which I don't have the mql4 file..
Trio Orchestra is better than Ilan TrioKS in backtest, which is not identical to AF Global..
I'm testing Trio Orchestra on a real account, and I'm quite sure that with the correct initial lot, the right max amount of positions and the max number of lots it will survive almost any market condition on EURUSD..that's why I'm asking you these adjustments