• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA EA I have programmed - York131

PCWalker

PCWalker

Member
Credit Hunter
Credits
5
To all my Friends, Traders, and Wonders, Would like to share with you an EA I have programmed, Hope you can give me some feedback, Thank you.

Remember There is no such EA that works in all Market conditions, you should optimize the EA, and choose the settings that are most popular statistically, so you might hit the common denominator between what is virtual and that which is real.

And for all those who enjoy disliking others contribution to the forum, should rather share their opinion so We all can improve rather then wasting time by just pressing dislike without really having any understanding of what they are facing, and losing their money by blindly believing what they want to believe, without proper scientific formalities.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Try the pairs you like, any timeframe, and optimize it with deep data mining of the optimization results with excel, it will work very well, but you need to limit the risks and watch on the profit factor. That is the only way you will find this EA or any other EA profitable. There are EAs that enables set and forget. but those enable optimization and data minding in real time.
 
Last edited:
Trader4711 said:
Sorry but not looks good

First, you don't need to be sorry, and thank you for making the effort, It is understandable, Let me explain to you something about EAs, they are computer programs that will perform well under only certain conditions, they will not stand all market conditions, if anyone tells you that his EA will work in any market conditions, he is lying to you. And that is why I wrote : "and optimize it with deep data mining of the optimization results with excel." I suppose you don't know what does that mean. It means that you need to go through the optimization process, get all the results into Microsoft Excel spreadsheet, and choose results that fall in the most "popular" statistically, so that when you use the EA the next time in live market, you MAY hit the same popular results as the one you choose statistically. That way EAs are suppose to work. And that is why you will never find any EA that will work in all market conditions.
Click to expand...

Do you know how to read the following graph and choose the most popular statistically?
 

Attachments

  • TesterGraph5M.gif
    TesterGraph5M.gif
    30.8 KB · Views: 146
Last edited:
I am sorry, I don't have a setting files, because the optimization process should be made on your broker, with a pair you want to trade, and your selected time frame. Then you should look at the graph of the whole optimization process and choose an area of clustered points that are most populated and with the highest density, and select a point right in the middle, this is not a accurate measurement, but to do it numerically you need to use Microsoft Excel, and Some statistical work, But That is much more complex, as it needs constant process every time the population changes according to the results produced by the influence of Market dynamics. In Addition, This graph changes from time to time, you also need to choose according to which parameters you want to measure the population relative to what kind of risk\reward ratio you are willing to endure, different parameters will create different picture of the population, therefor only high level statistical process can really optimize the selection, and I guess now you would also understand why most of the EAs are failing, because they need to be optimized in real time, and Metatrader is not able to do that, unless you have some serious additions to the platform.

Never the less, you can always take a chance, and choose the point wisely, and learn from your selections, that is the only way you will find the right setting parameters and success.

Now A question arises : What do you think would be the selection of most of the people who don't understand this process?

TesterGraph5M.gif
 
Last edited:
its a kind of heatmap to take position right ?
guess still need mathlab / R touch to make it understandable.
good luck everybody
 
Blantik Receh said:
its a kind of heatmap to take position right ?
guess still need mathlab / R touch to make it understandable.
good luck everybody
Click to expand...
More or less, the heatmap approach is somewhat limited because you would have only 2 dimensional array in addition to the limits of MQL.
But you are correct, one needs dynamical programming approach to solve these nonlinear problems.
By the way, thank you for the response and opinion, but R and Matlab are kind of slow for what is really needed in this market.
 
Thank you very much for sharing your personal robot !
Did some test with different settings for a while on backtest (90%) EURUSD H1 (for what is it worth...not so trustable I know..)
Results: deposit 3000, profitfactor: 13.37, max drawdown: 1.66%, expected payoff: 10.82, total trades: 11 with 1 loss trade, win: 118.99 Euro
It was a short time run from 29/09/2015 till 07/11/2015
this was my best setfile so far...hope this helps a bit in the search for the best set file for this robot.
Cheers mates !
 

Attachments

Does anyone know how to compare the performance of two different EAs, and state which EA is performing better and why?
 
PCWalker said:
Try to express a full question, with What, Why? Where? .... more then 8-15 words question that way we will know what are you asking. Thank you.
Click to expand...
Why not move the stop loss, the original list, without moving the stop loss on the loss
 
Can Anyone tell me what is the difference between the two following graphs? any opinions and ideas will be welcomed. The Two optimization where made on the EURUSD between 06.30.16 and 06.24.16 : Thank you.
55487116.gif
55578766.gif
 
EURUSD M15 2015/01/01 to 2016/09/30 same jimmy settings except:

pADX_DIMINUS_1 and pADX_2 back to default and MinimumSLPT set to 50

79 closed trades, 75 wins ... doesn´t taste good?


TesterGraph.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top