1. Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)
    Dismiss Notice

New EA The Logic Behind Optimization Probability York131.1

Discussion in 'Expert Advisor atau Robot Forex' started by PCWalker, 27 Oct 2016.

  1. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Dear Traders, Look at the following two graphs, and check which Optimization graph represents better trading Robot?

    Back Testing with a specific setting values, will not prove the Expert is working. Therefor the optimization process is need to be done in full with the below Instructions.

    A
    55487116.gif
    B
    55578766.gif

    As we know for a fact that optimization process with genetic algorithms, shuffle the external variables of the robot similar to a binary search, in order to find the highest results of the developing population of results as the evolutions of the cells performing the search for the optimal settings. (ref : OptimizingWithGA.PDF - https://www.msi.umn.edu/sites/default/files/OptimizingWithGA.pdf )

    In Order to select the most probable and profitable settings for the external variables, by examining the Y axis of a desired Profit, you will need to check how many of those in the X axis have succeed in producing the same profit. As an example lets take the two graphs above, and check visually, which of the two have more population in relation to a selected Y axis profit. If we look carefully, for example in Graph B the Profit of 180 USD has the least amount of population as the X is increased. One should also take into account the number of produced results in the X axis, as the number of results increase the probability of the expert increases for it's success. Which Means that, the probability of having profit with external variables selected in the area of 180 USD, is low relative to the 180 USD value in the Y Axis of graph A.

    In short, from the above two graphs as an example you can test and compare any different expert advisors with the two graphs produced by the optimization process, keeping in mind that these graphs change for different time frames and different conditions of the Market.
     

    Attached Files:

    Last edited: 23 Dec 2016
    • Like Like x 2
    • Informative Informative x 1
  2. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    New version to be out soon.

    Here is another graph of what it would mean a better performing Expert Compared to the previous two. If we look also at the number of successful results, you will notice there is a higher number of results on the X axis, which should also be checked with the total number of iteration the optimization process has performed. If you divide the number of pass iterations by the total number of iterations processed, you will get a approximate percentage of the success you might expect of the Expert Advisor. This success rate decreases rapidly the more you can see large number of separations in the graph, which means the larger the empty spaces the more the decrease of success rate.

    55578767.gif
    Total iterations : 7172/11264 = 63%
    55487116.gif
    Total iterations : 6795/14750 = 46%
    55578766.gif
    Total iterations : 4019/19650 = 20%
     
    Last edited: 28 Oct 2016
    • Like Like x 1
  3. BigStackBully

    BigStackBully Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hello PCWalker,
    your contribution looks very professional.

    I have 2 questions:
    1) what is the edge your system has? what inefficiencis does it exploit?
    2) real accounts on myfxbook?


    Thanks
     
  4. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    If you try to explain to me what do you mean by edge, and inefficiencies, I will try to answer you.
    You need to try it, study it, and learn to trade it until you will have the experience of applying it to a real account.
     
  5. BigStackBully

    BigStackBully Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hello PCWalker,

    thanks for answering..

    "You need to try it, study it..."
    OK. Give me MQL4 -- no further questions
     
  6. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Why don't you study programming, a little mathematics, and work on something that you feel will be professional, and then you will not need my Expert.
    That is much better then just trying to study someone's code. And if you feel I am wrong, then you can share with me some of your own ideas, and I will try to share mine.
    Thank you.
     
    • Like Like x 2
  7. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Thank you ZeroHundred, It is relatively advance compared to looking only at a single outcome most users choose to judge the performance of an EA. But if they read all my posts, they will understand that it is a waste of time to check a EA only by one single outcome of one single settings, because that settings will never have the exact market conditions as it previously had when it was created.
     
    Last edited: 29 Nov 2016
  8. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Does anyone know how an Expert decides to buy or sell?
     
  9. gokol

    gokol New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    5/5,
    This is my review for this thread:
    Thx
     
  10. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Thank you, Gokol... Now you only need to start using Zorro Trader.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  11. gokol

    gokol New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    thank you, bro I'll try it out.
     
  12. kliverz

    kliverz New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    thanks for share, its automatic EA or just indicator of ur system trade ?
     
  13. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    It is an EA, Dear Kliverz
     
  14. JAY SDA

    JAY SDA New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    i just read on zorro trader,,sound like interesting
     
  15. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    You can download, and start programming in less then 5 Min.
     
  16. JAY SDA

    JAY SDA New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    are you has used zorro trader at now ?
     
  17. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Yes, I am using Zorro Trader all the time.
     
  18. yosi408

    yosi408 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    good in real ?
     
    • Dumb Dumb x 1
  19. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    No, one can answer that question, because no one can predict the market.
    If you read all my posts, you will understand why?
     
    • Agree Agree x 1
  20. PCWalker

    PCWalker Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    If anyone can really feel the logic of my post, and can understand the importance of it, please share the article with all your friends, and trader, programmers, and others, that we may increase the awareness and success of all of us together, to bring better and more prosperity to our community.

    Thank you.
     
    • Like Like x 1

Share This Page