• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion I will make a Free EA with your Indicator

Reader mode
srivegunta992 said:
Hello Master Tanaka
Reagarding the Halftrend+RSI the opposite signal close function is not working,The EA is not closing on the opposite signal
One more question is Daily target is pips or money

Thank You and looking forward for your help
Click to expand...
Can you try in demo? I see sometimes opposite close does not work in backtest.
Can you check in demo account?
 
Whale said:
As a side note I am yet to find a profitable EA made by Mr.Tanaka ....
At least the ones are published here ....

Maybe he has private ones that are profitable and safe to use ....
Just my 2 cents ....
Click to expand...
No none of Mr. Tanaka's EAs are profitable ... has programming logic that cannot be profitable.
 
mag00 said:
:ok: Wellcome back, Tanaka !! :)

:talking: Great to see you again ...! :talking:

(I would have
a new strategy with
a new indicator
to test and share)
but first ...

... my compliments for
the huge amount of work done
in this Forum (!!)

I have analyzed it in BT / FT
and much of the result is described here

I found the DD in the EA-Anhtran template very low ...
(https://soehoe.id/i-will-make-a-free-ea-with-your-indicator.t9801/page-915)
and I would ask you ...
... if you can see and improve the entry (late?) in the original EA and
also replace the Rsi with the % W in another version and
the CCi in another one, again ...

Cheers
magOO

P.S.
The buy and sell levels
referred to% W and CCi
are very important ...
Click to expand...


there are several ...
and other ones ...

P.S.
unfortunately
martingales increase
DDs ...
 
Francesco60 said:
Please show us one profitable Tanaka EA ...
Click to expand...

zuko zk, Francesco60 is right ....

For example, Mr.Tanaka made an ea based on the Beast Super Signal ....

I tested it and it only generates loss after loss ....

I got one of my friends to code it for me with additional ideas added by me ....

I am testing it now on the major pairs M5 TF and the results are astonishing .....

10-12$ is the profit of each transaction with less than 5% DD .....

I will test more pairs and more TFs and I am sure that it's really a beast EA .....

I will continue to improve it and then will throw it on one of my real accounts with low spread and zero commision .....
 
tanaka akiko said:
Opps... Sorry I found a bug .. Now fixed it.
View attachment 145263

https://streamable.com/ieeu9m
Click to expand...
mr tanaka the sell conditions are fine but the buy conditions are not, remember that for buy orders they are the following:
needs confirmation of all 3 indicators (this condition is fine )
you need the blue line to be greater than the yellow line (this condition is fine)
if the blue line is already higher than the yellow line they need to be below the lower black line. (this is not respected by the algorithm, only the first two conditions)
 
mag00 said:
:ok: Wellcome back, Tanaka !! :)

:talking: Great to see you again ...! :talking:

(I would have
a new strategy with
a new indicator
to test and share)
but first ...

... my compliments for
the huge amount of work done
in this Forum (!!)

I have analyzed it in BT / FT
and much of the result is described here

I found the DD in the EA-Anhtran template very low ...
(https://soehoe.id/i-will-make-a-free-ea-with-your-indicator.t9801/page-915)
and I would ask you ...
... if you can see and improve the entry (late?) in the original EA and
also replace the Rsi with the % W in another version and
the CCi in another one, again ...

Cheers
magOO

P.S.
The buy and sell levels
referred to% W and CCi
are very important ...
Click to expand...

I have several EAs that end
the BT in profit:

the problem is to risk
with martingales
on your own
(and not on someone else's account, demo be it ...)
and then share the experience ...

The ideal is to have an EA
with a low / very low DD
and test it in demo

P.S.
I have this one...
... not among
the best in the Dax (m5)
Remember to delete the suffix(.txt)
 

Attachments

Whale said:
zuko zk, Francesco60 is right ....

For example, Mr.Tanaka made an ea based on the Beast Super Signal ....

I tested it and it only generates loss after loss ....

I got one of my friends to code it for me with additional ideas added by me ....

I am testing it now on the major pairs M5 TF and the results are astonishing .....

10-12$ is the profit of each transaction with less than 5% DD .....

I will test more pairs and more TFs and I am sure that it's really a beast EA .....

I will continue to improve it and then will throw it on one of my real accounts with low spread and zero commision .....
Click to expand...
why not share with the community?
 
tanaka akiko said:
Can you try in demo? I see sometimes opposite close does not work in backtest.
Can you check in demo account?
Click to expand...
Hello Master,
I am forward testing it on demo it sometimes isn't closing on opposite signal,
One more thing i want to let you know is that,can you please change the opposite signal close to just halftrend siganl
for example :if halftrend is buy and RSi is above 60 it takes buy,the trade has to close when halftrend chages to sell,
the EA should not wait till RSI also crosses 40

Thank you for your support and help in making this EA changes.jpg
 

Attachments

srivegunta992 said:
Hello Master,
I am forward testing it on demo it sometimes isn't closing on opposite signal,
One more thing i want to let you know is that,can you please change the opposite signal close to just halftrend siganl
for example :if halftrend is buy and RSi is above 60 it takes buy,the trade has to close when halftrend chages to sell,
the EA should not wait till RSI also crosses 40

Thank you for your support and help in making this EA View attachment 145472
Click to expand...

Ok, I changed code to close with only half trend opposite signal.
 

Attachments

Marco Antonio Dorantes m said:
mr tanaka the sell conditions are fine but the buy conditions are not, remember that for buy orders they are the following:
needs confirmation of all 3 indicators (this condition is fine )
you need the blue line to be greater than the yellow line (this condition is fine)
if the blue line is already higher than the yellow line they need to be below the lower black line. (this is not respected by the algorithm, only the first two conditions)
Click to expand...

Can you draw buy and sell entry ?

upload_2022-4-26_12-7-58.png
 

Attachments

  • upload_2022-4-26_12-7-58.png
    upload_2022-4-26_12-7-58.png
    29.4 KB · Views: 483
pugspuggy said:
Hi Tanaka san,

I was testing the EA_Coral . Does anyone noticed that the EA is not operating to what it should be?

Shouldn't the EA open and close trade based on the Pink and blue bar? It does not seem to be working based on these rules.

I noticed that the EA is not reacting this way as what it should be.

Not sure if the other memebers noticed the same. You will notice if you don't set TP and SL (attack martingale should not be set as well).

This is just my observations. Hopefully others can feedback. This is a potential good EA, but just that it does not react to what it should be doing.


View attachment 145432
Click to expand...



Update on my observation through my forward test of this EA_Coral:

1) EA does open and close near to the pink and blue bar, although it does only on the hour mark if you set the TF to H1.

2) When opposite close is activated, it closes the current open trade, it does not immediately open the opposite direction. So far I observed that it may open only at the next hourly candle. Not sure if its a bug or it is just that way.

3) There is 'noise' signal coming in during the process of a trend when an open trade is active. Meaning if I have a SELL trade during a downtrend, during the process of this trend, a BUY signal is activated and caused the SELL trade to close prematurely due to opposite signal. One way I tried to overcome this is to set to TRUE on 'close_only_profit' in the EA settings. But still this is not ideal and should not be the way how the EA should react. It should not have 'noise' signal casuing the trade to close prematurely.

If you guys interested to test it out, here is my set file.
 

Attachments

Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top