• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion I will make a Free EA with your Indicator

Reader mode
tanaka akiko said:
Hi, Jean for me in backtest it works both buy and sell. I still dont know why. I wonder if it depens on broker?
Click to expand...
Hi Tanaka ,

I am testing EA TMA CG mladen never repaint but in the journal I get the error that the file "TMA CG mladen never repaint" cannot be opened so the EA does not use the indy and the trades are open all the time without TMA signal which is most important important...is this a bug or something because I have many versions of TMA indy ......

I know that this is an oldest version of TMA EA but this is the only one functioning where I found TMA SETTINGS IN THE INPUTS which is also extremly important. We cannot test your limited default settings only, we must be able to change them.

Maybe it is the easiest for you instead of dealing with this problem that I post "True TMA " indy here and you make EA with your latest template with this indy. It is a not repainting one that shows accurate history if you scroll back in the chart.

BUT PLEASE INCLUDE THE INDY INPUTS IN THE EA INPUT so that they could be changed while testing...


Thanks for your answer...
 

Attachments

  • ScreenHunter 277.png
    ScreenHunter 277.png
    64.1 KB · Views: 117
  • TmaTrue .ex4
    TmaTrue .ex4
    5.2 KB · Views: 28
Last edited:
BluePanther said:
Yes, it is strange, as this problem was occurring on all my accounts only at Market Close every day (New York 5pm).

Now it is occurring constantly on one terminal only - my other account is not showing this problem (yet).

I remove the chart and start again, and still having problem.
I restart MT4 and still having problem.

I have another EA with similar bug issue, but MT4 restart fixes it until next time.

Journal log on terminal where SuperArrow still working:
View attachment 87736

Journal log on terminal where SuperArrow is not working:
View attachment 87737
Click to expand...
hi brothers,
what i have is not the same error of yours..
upload_2019-6-8_19-47-13.png
no basket issues but fortunately i have got an slow indicator and needs to re-write as per the journal but still doing its job..
having the same issues for my hedge and Solo FT..
 

Attachments

  • upload_2019-6-8_19-47-13.png
    upload_2019-6-8_19-47-13.png
    45.6 KB · Views: 1,037
kris ronquillo said:
hi brothers,
what i have is not the same error of yours..
View attachment 87789
no basket issues but fortunately i have got an slow indicator and needs to re-write as per the journal but still doing its job..
having the same issues for my hedge and Solo FT..
Click to expand...

You can solve these errors with a faster/more performing VPS (indicator is too slow) and increasing max spread (from 20 to 30, it depends from your broker and type of account).
Instead I have another kind of error (common error) and I don't know why...superarrow_error.jpg
 

Attachments

  • superarrow_error.jpg
    superarrow_error.jpg
    179.1 KB · Views: 1,047
kris ronquillo said:
hi brothers,
what i have is not the same error of yours..
View attachment 87789
no basket issues but fortunately i have got an slow indicator and needs to re-write as per the journal but still doing its job..
having the same issues for my hedge and Solo FT..
Click to expand...

You use a different version of Super Arrows RevB?
I am still using the original.

Maybe RedHawk's suggestion for faster VPS will fix your issue? Not sure how to fix my issue or RedHawk's Common Error.
Why is SA EA attempting to close non-existent orders?
Could SA EA have too many parameters and need a rewrite to be less complex??
 

Attachments

BluePanther said:
You use a different version of Super Arrows RevB?
I am still using the original.

Maybe RedHawk's suggestion for faster VPS will fix your issue? Not sure how to fix my issue or RedHawk's Common Error.
Why is SA EA attempting to close non-existent orders?
Could SA EA have too many parameters and need a rewrite to be less complex??
Click to expand...

I'm using the same version you posted... rev.B.
I'm using FBS Standard account (demo).
Besides this week (the first I'm in test) I have a very good profit (on Demo) with 6 pairs (2 chart each) M1 on 1000 usd account. Drawntown max about 27%.
superarrow.jpg
 

Attachments

  • superarrow.jpg
    superarrow.jpg
    99.2 KB · Views: 1,026
tanaka akiko said:
Hi, Jean for me in backtest it works both buy and sell. I still dont know why. I wonder if it depens on broker?
Click to expand...

Hello, Tanaka, thank you very much for your work, I offer a new way of thinking, this market is guaranteed not to lose money first, in order to make money. Use a no redraw indicator, or a combination of two indicators, as an order signal. 0.1 lot, if stop loss, signal again, open order 0.2 lots, stop loss again, open order 0.4 lots next time. When earnings can balance past losses, subtract some lots, leaving 0.1 to go. If 0.1 starts to profit first, the next order is still 0.1. If it lose money, double it next time. As long as the indicator has a 40 % winning percentage. This is 100 % able to beat the market. Please consider my suggestion . I 'd love to share your coffee money. My English is so bad that I don't know how to upload the indicator. I suggest you use indicator<wan shell>. thanks
 
Hello, Tanaka, thank you very much for your work, I offer a new way of thinking, this market is guaranteed not to lose money first, in order to make money. Use a no redraw indicator, or a combination of two indicators, as an order signal. 0.1 lot, if stop loss, signal again, open order 0.2 lots, stop loss again, open order 0.4 lots next time. When earnings can balance past losses, subtract some lots, leaving 0.1 to go. If 0.1 starts to profit first, the next order is still 0.1. If it lose money, double it next time. As long as the indicator has a 40 % winning percentage. This is 100 % able to beat the market. Please consider my suggestion . I 'd love to share your coffee money. My English is so bad that I don't know how to upload the indicator. I suggest you use indicator<wan shell>. thanks。We can't predict the market, but one time it's right, but this time it balances the losses. If you can find an indicator of 50 % of the winning percentage, this method will surely succeed.
 
reteid2222 said:
I cant promise but I m sure the answer it 99% yes(for me)....it is only a question how much effort is needed....in the most cases it is better to recode the EA(if U know the strat)...and the results have to be VERY good to convince me to do this....
You have a small window where the information where the trades are...the name of the window is the same on every MT4...so just write a method with C# which reads the updates and read this method from a extern dll in your expert advisor...
Maybe just get the information over the standard DDE communiction....this will be an easier way of coding for the most guys(and girls :))
Click to expand...
It seem so hard for me that can only program "hello world" application... :D:D
 
Afrodeenn said:
Thankyou
Click to expand...
Just modified as I would do this...it s free for optimizing...I m convicened in the flat trading time there are very good setups...
 

Attachments

Last edited:
redhawk said:
You can solve these errors with a faster/more performing VPS (indicator is too slow) and increasing max spread (from 20 to 30, it depends from your broker and type of account).
Instead I have another kind of error (common error) and I don't know why...View attachment 87791
Click to expand...
I am getting the same kind of error = on my account. However the profits are very good.
 

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2019-06-08 at 4.28.57 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2019-06-08 at 4.28.57 PM.png
    396.3 KB · Views: 98
ShafiJR said:
Can some EA code expert advise what entry to be added on the source code if I need to pause all trades in case the equity reached a specific percentage of total balance amount..
Click to expand...

The code already in latest Tanaka san Template, to pause trade if equity drawdown reach some percentage. Further functions can choose, close only, close and pause trade or prefer pause only.
 
ywg forex said:
Hello, Tanaka, thank you very much for your work, I offer a new way of thinking, this market is guaranteed not to lose money first, in order to make money. Use a no redraw indicator, or a combination of two indicators, as an order signal. 0.1 lot, if stop loss, signal again, open order 0.2 lots, stop loss again, open order 0.4 lots next time. When earnings can balance past losses, subtract some lots, leaving 0.1 to go. If 0.1 starts to profit first, the next order is still 0.1. If it lose money, double it next time. As long as the indicator has a 40 % winning percentage. This is 100 % able to beat the market. Please consider my suggestion . I 'd love to share your coffee money. My English is so bad that I don't know how to upload the indicator. I suggest you use indicator<wan shell>. thanks
Click to expand...

similar to my strategy , if we can find sweet ratio between TP SL and EA with decent winning ratio , sure will beat the market, one weakness , some EA will sometime have long consecutive loose trade, account balance can can blown quickly if we dont limit the double lot. You can try the strategy with some EA here , already coded and with template feature suitable with the strategy.

to upload indicator just attach it in your comment here.
 
Hello Tanaka,
Hope to program this idea is possible.
The idea is linked to the Bollinger bands indi. 1hr TF
The EA is required to open a trade once a breakout happened either upper or lower bands after a certain pips.
Example, if the price broke the lower band and move away for >10 pips then buy trade is opened with TP xx and SL xx
The same goes for the upper band after break then sell trade
The number of pips break from the BB to be variable as it needs to be tweaked for every pair based on statistics

Is it possible to be programmed...

Thanks for your help.
 
Hi bros/siss,
Quality indicator is the must for entry, eg. RSI, MACD, Stoch etc... We can starts martingale from signal entry, im looking for this kind of strategy or you can set the SL n TP if the signal is not good.
 
Thanks for your help the last time mr tanaka.. you are the best.

I have another request if you don’t mind.

Can you make a trailing stop ea base on fractals?

- the position will close when a lower or upper fractal is form, user preference

- An option to “close position only if in profit” - user preference.

Fractals are good trailing stops.

Thank you.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top