• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA Auto Trading Portfolio (Free EA, No Expiration)

Reader mode
Jean-Leon said:
Hi autotradingportfolio,
I downloaded the version 4.0 for EURGBP. It seems that there's an error in coding (590,16 = Array out of range). Can you confirm and modify it please for I can launch my backtest since 2005 ?
Regards
Click to expand...
Hi Jean-Leon

I need more information from you.

Did you also get error from another pairs (version 4.0)?
Did you get error if you backtest it from 2007?
Did you get the error if you backtest it (EURGBP EA) with another pairs?
Did you get error if you use bar opening instead of every tick?

Best regards.
 
Last edited:
autotradingportfolio said:
Dear traders,
ATP Prototype EURGBP 4.0 H1 has been uploaded, please check the first post.
Also please reduce your Risk_Multiplier if you trade multiple pairs.
The portfolio result for all 3 pairs is attached below.
Best regards.
Click to expand...

Dear autotradingportfolio ,
as you know i have backtested all 10 pairs with TDS v2. for past ten years, period 2008-2018.
All results were amazing, so i put the expert (v.1) in live on my cent account starting from 25-06-2018 with 0.01 and later with 0.10
As you can see from the tables enclosed, the results are poor. Yes it is only two months but no gains....

Also.
Checking the backtests on this thread concering the various versions, from what i can see V1 has teorically best gain in the history. Why should be better V4 if it has worse results?
 

Attachments

  • a.PNG
    a.PNG
    20.8 KB · Views: 56
  • b.PNG
    b.PNG
    7.9 KB · Views: 54
Raffus said:
Dear autotradingportfolio ,
as you know i have backtested all 10 pairs with TDS v2. for past ten years, period 2008-2018.
All results were amazing, so i put the expert (v.1) in live on my cent account starting from 25-06-2018 with 0.01 and later with 0.10
As you can see from the tables enclosed, the results are poor. Yes it is only two months but no gains....

Also.
Checking the backtests on this thread concering the various versions, from what i can see V1 has teorically best gain in the history. Why should be better V4 if it has worse results?
Click to expand...
Please you can share the statement to be more clear >
Thx
 
Raffus said:
Dear autotradingportfolio ,
as you know i have backtested all 10 pairs with TDS v2. for past ten years, period 2008-2018.
All results were amazing, so i put the expert (v.1) in live on my cent account starting from 25-06-2018 with 0.01 and later with 0.10
As you can see from the tables enclosed, the results are poor. Yes it is only two months but no gains....

Also.
Checking the backtests on this thread concering the various versions, from what i can see V1 has teorically best gain in the history. Why should be better V4 if it has worse results?
Click to expand...

It is simply the short timeframe. I can confirm the bad results until now on my 10k live account starting from early June. But since the EA manages trades up to one full year we are still far from a reliable judgement.

A friend of mine started end of July and got much better results until now. It is the market. Some pairs were caught on the wrong side in the past weeks. Be patient and let it work at least for 6-12 month. This is a longterm EA. Temporary losses are always part of the game.
 
Drolph said:
It is simply the short timeframe. I can confirm the bad results until now on my 10k live account starting from early June. But since the EA manages trades up to one full year we are still far from a reliable judgement.

A friend of mine started end of July and got much better results until now. It is the market. Some pairs were caught on the wrong side in the past weeks. Be patient and let it work at least for 6-12 month. This is a longterm EA. Temporary losses are always part of the game.
Click to expand...

Wise comment. The most reliable thing today is to check that BT 06-08 is near FT 06-08. If no, don't trust 2008-2018 BT. If yes, no worry about the loss for the moment.
 
autotradingportfolio said:
Hi Jean-Leon

I need more information from you.

Did you also get error from another pairs (version 4.0)?
Did you get error if you backtest it from 2007?
Did you get the error if you backtest it (EURGBP EA) with another pairs?
Did you get error if you use bar opening instead of every tick?

Best regards.
Click to expand...
Hi autotradingportfolio,
1) No error from another pairs with version 4.0 (AUDUSD and EURCHF).
2) If backtest begin from 01.01.2007, indeed, no error with EURGBP version 4.0
3) If I backtest EURGBP v4.0 with another pair (EURUSD for example) from 01.01.2005, same error appears (Array out of range)
4) If I backtest EURGBP v4.0 on the pair EURGBP from 01.01.2005, esing bar opening, no error message appears.

also, the question is why don't have the problem with EURCHF and AUDUSD v4.0 ?

Regards
 
autotradingportfolio said:
Hi Jean-Leon ,

Thank you for the information you gave, could you please test the AUDUSD or EURCHF EA with your EURGBP data and see if it give you an error or not?

Best regards.
Click to expand...
Hi autotradingportfolio,
As you requested, I backtested ATPPrototype AUDUSD and EURCHF (v4.0) with EURGBP data from 01.01.2005 ; no error message appears.
Hope that test can help you to continue to develop this very good EA...
Regards
 
Jean-Leon said:
Hi autotradingportfolio,
As you requested, I backtested ATPPrototype AUDUSD and EURCHF (v4.0) with EURGBP data from 01.01.2005 ; no error message appears.
Hope that test can help you to continue to develop this very good EA...
Regards
Click to expand...
Hi Jean-Leon ,

Thank you for your help,

Could you please test these basic version of EURGBP on 2005 data, only one month is fine, and see if your error still exist.

Best regards.
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Holy crap!!! these EA's trade like they are on crack!!! But they give some pretty interesting results in the long term. Thanks for sharing, I will do lots of BT'ing.
 
autotradingportfolio said:
Hi Jean-Leon ,

Thank you for your help,

Could you please test these basic version of EURGBP on 2005 data, only one month is fine, and see if your error still exist.

Best regards.
Click to expand...
Hi autotradingportfolio,
As you requested, I tested the three version from 01.01.2005 on EURGBP data.
1) The version "test" give the same error (array out of range) ; the version "test awesome" is ok ; the version "Test candle" give the error (aray out of range).
2) please, note that if you begin the backtest from 01.01.2007, all the versions are ok.
Regards
 
Jean-Leon said:
Hi autotradingportfolio,
As you requested, I tested the three version from 01.01.2005 on EURGBP data.
1) The version "test" give the same error (array out of range) ; the version "test awesome" is ok ; the version "Test candle" give the error (aray out of range).
2) please, note that if you begin the backtest from 01.01.2007, all the versions are ok.
Regards
Click to expand...
Thank you very much,

It seems that we're gonna need your help once again. I'll inform you later.

Best regards.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top