Question SmartECN MT4 Expert Advisor

[mkowa]

thanks , mkowa.....
can i ask you for one more test with following setting:
Initial Deposit 200$, start January 2019 ~ January 2020, spread 15
Risk Percent = 0
Fixed Lot = 0.05
others default.

Thanks in Advance
really appreciate.

Ok. But I have to download the data first.

 

[giomantov]

It IS 99.9% even if you read "n/a". But you are free to not believe it.

Tickstory has 99%. Despite that its not true and bad. Tickdata is real backtest with 99.90% with slippage, commissions, variable spread.

 

[blackking]

If during backtest is a good result, I think will make more confidence to forward in a live account
but maybe the amount capital as starting capital also become one consideration

 

[co_boi]

does anyone have try it on real account?
how is the result?

 

[suenk]

does anyone have try it on real account?
how is the result?

i will start next week...hope we can make some profit.

 

[co_boi]

i will start next week...hope we can make some profit.

mine on forward demo doesn't open a transaction
is it not open daily?

 

[suenk]

the profit factor is quite good

mine on forward demo doesn't open a transaction
is it not open daily?

please do some backtest first, you will understand the logic behind this EA, EA take order at night only

 

[mkowa]

thanks , mkowa.....
can i ask you for one more test with following setting:
Initial Deposit 200$, start January 2019 ~ January 2020, spread 15
Risk Percent = 0
Fixed Lot = 0.05
others default.

Here you are. I do nat know why my results are different from yours. Tickstory IS also 99.9%

 

[mkowa]

Tickstory has 99%. Despite that its not true and bad. Tickdata is real backtest with 99.90% with slippage, commissions, variable spread.

You are right that there is no variable spread. But it is 99.9%. No offence.

 

[suenk]

You are right that there is no variable spread. But it is 99.9%. No offence.
View attachment 123959

Thanks, mkowa...
but i still dont understand why the BT is so different between you and my other friend, both of you use 99.9% ....

 

[Arcanaeum]

Tested some different configs for you. All H1, $200 balance, variable spread, slippage. With TickDataSuite. Spreads are similar to an ECN account - quite tight. This EA did not respond well to larger spreads.

It is hard to make a good profit with such a small balance without excessive risk. I do think there are better options out there for small account balances. I'd also recommend longer backtests before going live.

 

[suenk]

Tested some different configs for you. All H1, $200 balance, variable spread, slippage. With TickDataSuite. Spreads are similar to an ECN account - quite tight. This EA did not respond well to larger spreads.

It is hard to make a good profit with such a small balance without excessive risk. I do think there are better options out there for small account balances. I'd also recommend longer backtests before going live.

Thanks a lot... really appreciate this.

 

[mandymandy]

this EA is the red eye EA and both have the same trouble they work for first time only then they stop working