• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion I will make a Free EA with your Indicator

Reader mode
I appreciate Mr. Tanaka's work, but I have never found a positive EA of his. Many EAs but all negative.
It is not a controversy but it is only the reality after so many tests.
 
Whale said:
Hi Mr. Tanaka

On the FT there is something wrong with this EA based on Noble impulse ....

the signals does not match at all with the buying and selling arrows ....

And hence very bad performance at FT ....

Need fixing ....

Cheers

P.S If you're interested to fix it, I will provide you with an excellent indicator for filtering the signals .....
Click to expand...

Oh, maybe it is because of Grid order?
Please check the below picture.
You can try with attached set file.
It is BUY-SELL-BUY-SELL entry.
You can try FT to see if BUY entry is closed by next SELL signal.

upload_2022-1-27_12-0-55.png
 

Attachments

  • upload_2022-1-27_12-0-55.png
    upload_2022-1-27_12-0-55.png
    26.3 KB · Views: 640
  • upload_2022-1-27_12-1-18.png
    upload_2022-1-27_12-1-18.png
    35.8 KB · Views: 126
  • EA_noble-impulse-indicator.set
    EA_noble-impulse-indicator.set
    3 KB · Views: 42
Francesco60 said:
I appreciate Mr. Tanaka's work, but I have never found a positive EA of his. Many EAs but all negative.
It is not a controversy but it is only the reality after so many tests.
Click to expand...
majority of indicator's are repacked , renamed, sold as premium, and generally don't work as seen on chart. A lot's of fake reviews for both indy's and EA's.
When market makes wild swings like today around 2pm, eastern time, how do you create indy or rule for that, and that wasn't bad , but there are moment's when accounts could be wiped.
People are waiting for dinner to be served on plate, but it's not how life works, one has to work to get that.

Mr. Tanaka does what people ask him to do, and we are lucky to have him, but most of time those same(above mentioned) people have no clue how those indicators or EA's work, and are not willing to spend time to learn about it, expecting miracle.
 
petar said:
majority of indicator's are repacked , renamed, sold as premium, and generally don't work as seen on chart. A lot's of fake reviews for both indy's and EA's.
When market makes wild swings like today around 2pm, eastern time, how do you create indy or rule for that, and that wasn't bad , but there are moment's when accounts could be wiped.
People are waiting for dinner to be served on plate, but it's not how life works, one has to work to get that.

Mr. Tanaka does what people ask him to do, and we are lucky to have him, but most of time those same(above mentioned) people have no clue how those indicators or EA's work, and are not willing to spend time to learn about it, expecting miracle.
Click to expand...
That s 100% true.... when the EA is ready the works for the users just begins!
 
petar said:
majority of indicator's are repacked , renamed, sold as premium, and generally don't work as seen on chart. A lot's of fake reviews for both indy's and EA's.
When market makes wild swings like today around 2pm, eastern time, how do you create indy or rule for that, and that wasn't bad , but there are moment's when accounts could be wiped.
People are waiting for dinner to be served on plate, but it's not how life works, one has to work to get that.

Mr. Tanaka does what people ask him to do, and we are lucky to have him, but most of time those same(above mentioned) people have no clue how those indicators or EA's work, and are not willing to spend time to learn about it, expecting miracle.
Click to expand...

You not quite right, not all the same
I`ve tested and observed Tradind flash EA and asked to do some modifications ,but my voice got ignored and that`s ok no worries will trade manually)) ,Target Bands EA you txt me about it i couldn`t find on this forum there is one on Tanakas website free for backtesting only . Demo/live version not available.
 
Hi Mr Tanaka

Please do you think it's possible to add to your EA the possibility to active or not alertforsignal, alertformobile, alertformail like the EA Peak &Valley 2022?
EA concerned are here.
Best Regards,
Ludovic
 

Attachments

Hi again Mr Tanaka,
In other way, please can you make EA like PEak & valley in my precedent post with this indicator if is not repaint?

green star = buy order
red star = sell order


Regards,
Ludovic
 

Attachments

Francesco60 said:
I appreciate Mr. Tanaka's work, but I have never found a positive EA of his. Many EAs but all negative.
It is not a controversy but it is only the reality after so many tests.
Click to expand...
Hello my friend.
I agree with you.
But you forgot one thing, and that is that we are the ones proposing the indicator so that Mr. Tanaka can turn it into EA for us.
In fact, Mr. Tanaka is not offering us anything, he is coding what we are ordering. Without any expectations.
Also, friends should not forget to invite Mr. Tanaka for a coffee.
 
Maximum EA that is made by Tanaka is useless.so i think he should be make profitable EA that we can make profit.
 
markw118 said:
You not quite right, not all the same
I`ve tested and observed Tradind flash EA and asked to do some modifications ,but my voice got ignored and that`s ok no worries will trade manually)) ,Target Bands EA you txt me about it i couldn`t find on this forum there is one on Tanakas website free for backtesting only . Demo/live version not available.
Click to expand...
it is on this forum, free for all, but you have to look for it , created by Mr. Tanaka, and has lot's of options.
 
petar said:
Just set it up on 30 min, higher TF should bring better results. Might need some fine tuning, if all good should be able to move it on VPS in couple of days.
USDJPY is making turn up north, it is at the beginning of swing, day chart, and 30 min chart. USDJPY, I find is good for swing trading.

Connected MT4 to myfxbook, so we shall see.

thx Mr. Tanaka !
Click to expand...
not ready to go to vps yet, have setup separate account for that EA, have few more ideas, wanna try them before let it run on it's own.
Going on vacation tomorrow, so won't have time to baby sit.

Imagine guys if one could get 3-5% daily, you do the calculation (https://www.thecalculatorsite.com/finance/calculators/daily-compound-interest.php).
I am open for ideas , place your indicators on the chart, and let it sit there for few days, that will give you true answer about indy.

We are lucky to have Mr. Tanaka willing to help us !
thx!
 

Attachments

  • EA_VSD.PNG
    EA_VSD.PNG
    63 KB · Views: 103
petar said:
not ready to go to vps yet, have setup separate account for that EA, have few more ideas, wanna try them before let it run on it's own.
Going on vacation tomorrow, so won't have time to baby sit.

Imagine guys if one could get 3-5% daily, you do the calculation (https://www.thecalculatorsite.com/finance/calculators/daily-compound-interest.php).
I am open for ideas , place your indicators on the chart, and let it sit there for few days, that will give you true answer about indy.

We are lucky to have Mr. Tanaka willing to help us !
thx!
Click to expand...
Good for you ! Thank you for your help.:cool:
 
petar said:
not ready to go to vps yet, have setup separate account for that EA, have few more ideas, wanna try them before let it run on it's own.
Going on vacation tomorrow, so won't have time to baby sit.

Imagine guys if one could get 3-5% daily, you do the calculation (https://www.thecalculatorsite.com/finance/calculators/daily-compound-interest.php).
I am open for ideas , place your indicators on the chart, and let it sit there for few days, that will give you true answer about indy.

We are lucky to have Mr. Tanaka willing to help us !
thx!
Click to expand...

Dear Peter san, Could you pls share all your indicator, EA and set files although all are available here but which working abnormal to my account
Thanks for your cordial response !
---
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top