• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion Contribution to this forum from me (Non-repaint very good signal indicator)

Zoog1 said:
I do not doubt your best intentions and much of what you say makes sense - ie price action. BUT and its a big but this really is not a good indicator. It looks like it in hindsight but not in realtime. If you look at the code its simply the RSI and a moving average thereof on a higher TF. The problem is not that it gives false signals but when the RSI touches (not crosses but touches) the MA it gives a signal, then if it retraces you get no signal because it has not retouched. I repeat again, all indicators based on a higher TF, will either repaint, backpaint or in this case no paint until the higher TF closes. You cannot get away from that however hard you try.
Click to expand...
Guys did u really read my posts at all form start on tread till now? What hindsihgts what nonsese.. I jsut post some whic i think its good indicator according me, which can show some singall i dindt say use it only this n trade. I stated very good few times it is useful and if u find it useufl for ur trading profile use it. Yes it give osme direction on higher timeframe, but if u dont find useful i said best is to learn to do analisis the price , and i even said whicjh according me are good courses and books which i learnt before.. Rest is up to u guys...
 
Not much point in replying to this thread anymore so this is my last post in it. Bobten seems to take comments personally whereas I and certainly RM were simply trying to point out the many flaws in this largely useless indicator. By the way, I agree with RM, the way to go is PA. I know many need the crutch that is afforded by indicators but if you remember that an indicator is only showing you what the price is doing on any given TF you will go a long way forward in your trading.
 
Zoog1 said:
Not much point in replying to this thread anymore so this is my last post in it. Bobten seems to take comments personally whereas I and certainly RM were simply trying to point out the many flaws in this largely useless indicator. By the way, I agree with RM, the way to go is PA. I know many need the crutch that is afforded by indicators but if you remember that an indicator is only showing you what the price is doing on any given TF you will go a long way forward in your trading.
Click to expand...
Simply u r some signal providers or something u see me as competition or no idea. But i see u r trying to switch the reality of what i said all this time into something nonsense really. RM said price action or PA is nonsese, it is stupid to learn price action, i said he is wrong and u r some supporter to him more than obvious , hence i stated many times everyone need to learn to price analysis and use support n resistance on higher timeframe , key area, shift points ect, I said go n see my posts since begging till now that i said people u msut learn price analisis and use S/R and ect... but u still write nonsense... U r trying to convert reality in front of the people here like i said YES GUYS trade and rely only on this indicator... Actually i even post on what i trade on my chart, S/R, switch point, EMA, RSI, pattern analysis, and even i said on what timeframes few times and what courses are best to try to learn i give directions to people here not to wonder but direct to point what to start to study. U r try to be smartass actually like RM, no idea why but obvious u r trying to convince people like i said to them dont study price action no use ema no rsi no S/R? its obviouse u r up to something ..
 
Last edited:
Retireme said:
My work here is done.... unwatched!
Click to expand...
\
Better cos u dont know really what is price analysis what is naked chart... I proof in live how i trade u only talk...I tried to help people to give direction what to study and where to start not to wonder around, while u do nothing ... obviuse u r some kind of person who is up to something against me
 
Retireme said:
Greetings to all. I see many requests for this indicator...

Here is the MQ4 file, I have converted it to English and added "Push" notifications.

Enjoy!
RM
Click to expand...
By the way i just notice u r the one who make this indicator with push function, Retiereme. If u against this indicator so much why u every try to support it and waste ur time to upgrade it and then to let people to use it? Shouldn't u simply say this indicator is craps?.. dont use it?... why u try to improve it few months ago ? You should simply protect the people instead to send this same indicator with upgraded PUSH function. U r totally controversial dude by urself. And read what i wrote when i open this tread.. it says SIGNAL INDICATOR. It doesn't says USE THIS INDICATOR ALONE ON CHARTS N TRADE IT. That why once i start the tread i said to the people here try to use in combination with other stuffs on the chart. And i even said what to use and even what courses to read to use price action and S/R and ect. but u did not try to give directions to the people obvious u r trying to mislead them n attack me nonsense. And yes ill tell u i do use this indicator once i open position ( with the analisis i do) then if i see this indicator appear means very big probability to hold the position lit bit more longer ...
 
Hi, guys who is from and live or it is at moment in Jakarta? I am at moment in Jakarta.. drop me a msg in inbox ....
 
[QUOTE = "Manjunath SR, post: 218940, участник: 32733"] Pls добавьте меня в вашу группу сэр. [/ QUOTE]
Pls добавьте меня в вашу группу сэр.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top