• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA Auto Trading Portfolio (Free EA, No Expiration)

Reader mode
manal said:
Sorry when started the account
Click to expand...

It does not Matter. Tests shows that oktober is negative also if you started all 10 pairs long time before. If you started at 01.10. it is "only" more negative"

october.PNG


and only october:

onlyoctober.PNG
 

Attachments

  • october.PNG
    october.PNG
    51 KB · Views: 312
  • onlyoctober.PNG
    onlyoctober.PNG
    34.7 KB · Views: 312
Last edited:
Probably highly optimized EA for 1o last years... but really promising pattern. Must be patient to see if future results can be like past.
 
dont forget, the coder said. it is longterm.. you can have a months with lost, but at the end of the year? what said the ea? :)
 
SimplePlan said:
This October is the first month since 2006 which will end negativ, as it seems. Can you confirm this?
Click to expand...
Yes, it's a negative month, and we hate to say it, but we can't deny curve fitting possibility and it's a nightmare for any EA developers.

We do what we can to minimize curvefitting, such as :
1. The EA only trade using open price method, not every tick, to make the backtesting process easier
2. It's backtested with quite long historical data since 2007,
3. It's backtested in bad trading environment with 17 pips (not points) spread and $3 commission,
4. It only use standard mt4 indicators,
5. We focus on stagnation and SQN, so the OOS period result is still similar to In sample period,
6. We're hesitant to use trailing stop because we're afraid it could drive us to further curve fitting,
7. We don't fully optimize the strategy, just partially.

Unfortunately even after doing all of the things above, the only method to know that your strategy is curve fitted or not is by throwing it in a live trading environment.

And here are some of our plan in the future :
1. We're gonna use longer historical data from 2003 to verify the result,
2. We're gonna use less indicator, we banned some indicators that have wide parameter such as ATR and Momentum,
3. We also plan to start a blog where we'll upload the updates on that blog instead of this thread. However we'll still give support to some members via PM.

Please excuse the EA it's still far far far from perfect.

Best regards.
 
Last edited:
autotradingportfolio said:
Yes, it's a negative month, and we hate to say it, but we can't deny curve fitting possibility and it's a nightmare for any EA developers.

We do what we can to minimize curvefitting, such as :
1. The EA only trade using open price method, not every tick, to make the backtesting process easier
2. It's backtested with quite long historical data since 2007,
3. It's backtested in bad trading environment with 17 pips (not points) spread and $3 commission,
4. It only use standard mt4 indicators,
5. We focus on stagnation and SQN, so the OOS period result is still similar to In sample period,
6. We're hesitant to use trailing stop because we're afraid it could drive us to further curve fitting,
7. We don't fully optimize the strategy, just partially.

Unfortunately even after doing all of the things above, the only method to know that your strategy is curve fitted or not is by throwing it in a live trading environment.

And here are some of our plan in the future :
1. We're gonna use longer historical data from 2003 to verify the result,
2. We're gonna use less indicator, we banned some indicators that have wide parameter such as ATR and Momentum,
3. We also plan to start a blog where we'll upload the updates on that blog instead of this thread. However we'll still give support to some members via PM.

Please excuse the EA it's still far far far from perfect.

Best regards.
Click to expand...


I really appreciate your effort and the communication here inside the forum, thanks for this detailed answer. This gives a good feeling and let us know that you really put a lot of work in this EAs. If I can help with development or backtesting or something else, just let me know.
 
alaakenanah said:
Thank you for sharing we have quotation which pairs made big loss on OCT 2018 ?
Click to expand...

I can tell you this, but which benefit would you have from this? Next month could be totally different again. 1 Month means nothing for a single pair with this type of EA. In the long run on backtest every pair is positive and makes good profit.
 
autotradingportfolio said:
Yes, it's a negative month, and we hate to say it, but we can't deny curve fitting possibility and it's a nightmare for any EA developers.

We do what we can to minimize curvefitting, such as :
1. The EA only trade using open price method, not every tick, to make the backtesting process easier
2. It's backtested with quite long historical data since 2007,
3. It's backtested in bad trading environment with 17 pips (not points) spread and $3 commission,
4. It only use standard mt4 indicators,
5. We focus on stagnation and SQN, so the OOS period result is still similar to In sample period,
6. We're hesitant to use trailing stop because we're afraid it could drive us to further curve fitting,
7. We don't fully optimize the strategy, just partially.

Unfortunately even after doing all of the things above, the only method to know that your strategy is curve fitted or not is by throwing it in a live trading environment.

And here are some of our plan in the future :
1. We're gonna use longer historical data from 2003 to verify the result,
2. We're gonna use less indicator, we banned some indicators that have wide parameter such as ATR and Momentum,
3. We also plan to start a blog where we'll upload the updates on that blog instead of this thread. However we'll still give support to some members via PM.

Please excuse the EA it's still far far far from perfect.

Best regards.
Click to expand...
Thank you for your explanation , still a great EA and also your team are great developers!
 
SimplePlan said:
I can tell you this, but which benefit would you have from this? Next month could be totally different again. 1 Month means nothing for a single pair with this type of EA. In the long run on backtest every pair is positive and makes good profit.
Click to expand...
Please, how do you do for backtest the 10 pairs at the same time ? Thanks
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top