• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA CyNera MT4 4.31 (no dll)

same for me, started sell order on Thursday night, and eventually hit SL on Friday. Thankfully on demo.
I found that there are differences in OpenAI analysis depending on the broker.
XM is fast at analyzing, Vantage is slow.
Incidentally, XM started trading at 17:30 and made a profit.
We need to find the right broker.
I am using a real account to compare XM, FXGT and Vantage.
 
Last edited:
I found that there are differences in OpenAI analysis depending on the broker.
XM is fast at analyzing, Vantage is slow.
Incidentally, XM started trading at 17:30 and made a profit.
We need to find the right broker.
I am using a real account to compare XM, FXGT and Vantage
It’s unlikely that ChatGPT's responses depend on the broker. The differences you're seeing are likely due to how ChatGPT interprets the prompt or the randomness in its analysis. Even with identical prompts, it can generate varying answers because it evaluates probabilities each time.

The differences in performance between brokers are more likely related to execution speed, spreads, or latency rather than ChatGPT itself
 
just use 3.8 or 4.00 for now it works best.. even no loss so far for me.. always in profit. I am using OctaFX and Exness as brokers.
 
just use 3.8 or 4.00 for now it works best.. even no loss so far for me.. always in profit. I am using OctaFX and Exness as brokers.
Back test results not look promising , even once in month if its SL all profit are gone , if we use Trailing SL profit are only with in 25 or less pips than that but no big losses.
 
It’s unlikely that ChatGPT's responses depend on the broker. The differences you're seeing are likely due to how ChatGPT interprets the prompt or the randomness in its analysis. Even with identical prompts, it can generate varying answers because it evaluates probabilities each time.

The differences in performance between brokers are more likely related to execution speed, spreads, or latency rather than ChatGPT itself
chatgpt performs analysis at fixed time intervals.
Approximately every 40 minutes.
Therefore, even if EA requests analysis results from OpenAI during that time, the results will be the same.
As dimgo said, it depends on the network environment.
We believe that a broker that communicates frequently with OpenAI in each environment is appropriate.
 
chatgpt performs analysis at fixed time intervals.
Approximately every 40 minutes.
Therefore, even if EA requests analysis results from OpenAI during that time, the results will be the same.
As dimgo said, it depends on the network environment.
We believe that a broker that communicates frequently with OpenAI in each environment is appropriate.

Give it a try yourself. Here's the prompt sent by Cynera—test it multiple times on ChatGPT, and you'll see different answers with the same prompt. This inconsistency makes it completely unreliable. Cynera's ChatGpt prompt : My EA wants to trade right now, please Give me just which Trade to put, SELL if you want to sell, BUY if you want to buy, NONE if you dont want to buy and sell and from a scale of 1 to 10 how precise that is. Nothing more. And give me how much Takeprofit should be, not lower then 25 and not higher then 45 and Stop Loss also (Stop Loss max. 294). Depends on your desicion and you analysis. You have this information to make your decision: Symbol: XAUUSD;Timeframe: M30;Should close very fast, almost without a Drawdown;Amount of High News Today: 2;RSI: 54.44;ATR: 3.12;MA Lower: 2620.19;MA Higher: 2605.19;MA Lower2: 2623.02;MA Higher2: 2619.75;. Say why in just a few words without mentioning the indicators and start with - after your decision. In this form:[BUY/SELL/NONE];[PRECISION X/10];[TP/SL];[WHY]. Without Punctuation marks. All In English language
 
I suggest everyone disable the AI feature because it's completely random. I installed the EA on two different terminals with the exact same configuration, and the results were entirely inconsistent. One terminal gave this signal: [SELL];[7/10];[35/150];[Price is nearing resistance and showing signs of reversal], while the other gave: [BUY];[6/10];[35/280];[Market shows bullish potential with recent upward movement and stability in prices]. Such discrepancies make it unreliable for consistent trading decisions
which version?

Screenshot_20241222-090603.jpg
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20241222-090603.jpg
    Screenshot_20241222-090603.jpg
    460.4 KB · Views: 466
Give it a try yourself. Here's the prompt sent by Cynera—test it multiple times on ChatGPT, and you'll see different answers with the same prompt. This inconsistency makes it completely unreliable. Cynera's ChatGpt prompt : My EA wants to trade right now, please Give me just which Trade to put, SELL if you want to sell, BUY if you want to buy, NONE if you dont want to buy and sell and from a scale of 1 to 10 how precise that is. Nothing more. And give me how much Takeprofit should be, not lower then 25 and not higher then 45 and Stop Loss also (Stop Loss max. 294). Depends on your desicion and you analysis. You have this information to make your decision: Symbol: XAUUSD;Timeframe: M30;Should close very fast, almost without a Drawdown;Amount of High News Today: 2;RSI: 54.44;ATR: 3.12;MA Lower: 2620.19;MA Higher: 2605.19;MA Lower2: 2623.02;MA Higher2: 2619.75;. Say why in just a few words without mentioning the indicators and start with - after your decision. In this form:[BUY/SELL/NONE];[PRECISION X/10];[TP/SL];[WHY]. Without Punctuation marks. All In English language
This kind of prompt is inaccurate because too few parameters are provided. AI itself has a certain degree of randomness. I'm planning to make modifications to it.
 
Iva been thinking to reduce the SL with about 100 points anyway its reaching it not very often but if it does the losses will be not so dramatical
If SL is reached, it will lose 8 winning trades.
So, I am considering lowering my risk level by another level.
I'll try my best to find a good setting too.:)
 
Back
Top