• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA Auto Trading Portfolio (Free EA, No Expiration)

Hi cho.steven,
Just a question : dis the EA open orders since friday morning on your account ?
Thanks for reply,
Regards
Hi Jean-Leon,

For my case the EA didnt't open order on that day.
Maybe there isnt setup condition on that day or maybe it already open a postion with the same strategy on the other day.

But after that the EA did open position.

Dear traders, ATP Prototype NZDUSD 4.0 H1 has been uploaded, please check the first post.

The portfolio report of all 7 pairs is attached below.

Best regards.

Thank you autotradingportfolio
Keep it up man.
 
Dear traders, ATP Prototype NZDUSD 4.0 H1 has been uploaded, please check the first post.

The portfolio report of all 7 pairs is attached below.

Best regards.

Well,

Regarding your backtest, I find it very strange that on last 10 years (i.e. 120 months), you only have 2 negative months while on forward testing on live account you have 4 consecutive negative months during last... 4 months.
Conclusion: BT=> 99% positive month, FT=> 0% positive month.

Your strategies are very very very overfitted.
 
Well,

Regarding your backtest, I find it very strange that on last 10 years (i.e. 120 months), you only have 2 negative months while on forward testing on live account you have 4 consecutive negative months during last... 4 months.
Conclusion: BT=> 99% positive month, FT=> 0% positive month.

Your strategies are very very very overfitted.
Version 4.0 for AUDUSD was launched first on August, and the other pairs were launched later.

It's impossible for members here to forward test it for 4 months.
 
Version 4.0 for AUDUSD was launched first on August, and the other pairs were launched later.

It's impossible for members here to forward test it for 4 months.

You understand what I mean.
Same BT for your old version 2.0.
What I see is lot of holy grail BT, and lot of negative accounts.
I can update an overfitted EA each month for his BT to be positive.
=> V4.0 will be negative for next months and you will update a "better" v5.0 with a positive BT on these months. Easy.
 
The portfolio report only calculate the closed profit and loss, it exclude the open trades (drawdown) from calculation.

For example you start with 10000 balance, in the end of the month if the closed trades is +500 and the open trades/drawdown is -1000 then you're considered in profit that month.
 
You understand what I mean.
Same BT for your old version 2.0.
What I see is lot of holy grail BT, and lot of negative accounts.
I can update an overfitted EA each month for his BT to be positive.
=> V4.0 will be negative for next months and you will update a "better" v5.0 with a positive BT on these months. Easy.
Version 3.0 or 4.0 is not replacement for version 2.0, they have completely different strategies, V2.0/2.9 is lack of visible TP and SL, V2.9 is basically V2.0 with Auto Lot feature, while V4.0 is V3.0 with Auto Lot feature, V3.0 is cancelled project because we can only manage to create the AUDUSD version. The only strategy improvement we do is AUDUSD V3.0 to V4.0.

We never claim our EA to be profitable or moreover a Holy Grail.
 
I agree. And you don' sell it.
But you or your team or whoever is the builder of that strategies should be aware of an huge overfitting effect which is obviously seeable.
Any strategy can be overfitted, but there're some methods we use to minimize overfitting.

1. The EA only trades on the bar open instead of every tick.
2. We tested the EA on last 10 years data.
3. We use 17 pips of spread, it's quite high in our opinion, originally, we also add $3 commision on each backtest, but we don't publish it in this forum.
4 We mostly pay attention on SQN and stagnation, stagnation play important role in our backtest.

However we cannot guarantee the future result.
 
Any strategy can be overfitted, but there're some methods we use to minimize overfitting.

1. The EA only trades on the bar open instead of every tick.
2. We tested the EA on last 10 years data.
3. We use 17 pips of spread, it's quite high in our opinion, originally, we also add $3 commision on each backtest, but we don't publish it in this forum.
4 We mostly pay attention on SQN and stagnation, stagnation play important role in our backtest.

However we cannot guarantee the future result.

Do you use StrategyQuant to code the EA (or purely in Mql4) ?
 
cho.steven
Thanks for share results... To make it follow these steps

1- portfolio > add account
2- edit buton account
3 setup permissions
 

Attachments

  • Captura.JPG
    Captura.JPG
    88.9 KB · Views: 118
Last edited:
autotradingportfolio hi sir , i have two question about your EA :
1) with 1000 account open 0.1 lots x position is correct ??
2) i want to FF test with your 7 pair and 1000 account , you suggest fixed 0.01 lots for trade or wich setting you recommended??

many thanks for sharing ...
 
cho.steven
Thanks for share results... To make it follow these steps

1- portfolio > add account
2- edit buton account
3 setup permissions
Thanks for the reply.
The problem is i canr change the permision to public. I dont know whats wrong haha.
It says need to verified account eventhoug i am using metatrader publisher.
 
autotradingportfolio hi sir , i have two question about your EA :
1) with 1000 account open 0.1 lots x position is correct ??
2) i want to FF test with your 7 pair and 1000 account , you suggest fixed 0.01 lots for trade or wich setting you recommended??

many thanks for sharing ...

Everything is explained in the first post - read carefully. You will lose your money if you start with only 1000$.
 
autotradingportfolio hi sir , i have two question about your EA :
1) with 1000 account open 0.1 lots x position is correct ??
2) i want to FF test with your 7 pair and 1000 account , you suggest fixed 0.01 lots for trade or wich setting you recommended??

many thanks for sharing ...
Hello, 1000 account is to small to trade all 7 pairs

Here's my suggestion :
- Please wait for all 10 pairs to be released
- Use demo account with 10000, and lower your risk level to 0.1
- Please leave another parameters to the default value.
- You may suffer loss on the early months
- The drawdown can last for months, so please prepare yourself

Best regards.
 
Back
Top