• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

Suggestion Xpert Ea

Lucas Acosta said:
You need to download the history so that this EA works both in real and in demo because it reads the supports and resistances of the past to open the orders.

If you do not download the history you can never open a simple order in FT.

Regards.
Click to expand...

Have you tried this XPERT(4) EA on demo?
I tried but support and resistance didnt move from where it was when i put that EA on chart?
Did it happen to you too?
 
This is my review for this thread:
The logic of this EA is close to the market law and is worthy of further research and improvement. Please continue your efforts.
 
nakanishi said:
i notice that the pivot line is not moving in Forward testing . but it moves in backtest.
may be we can start a new EA base on this idea. anyone?
Click to expand...

This ea seems to calculate the direction axis from the data of the past and future tenses, so the backtest results are good, just like you now travel back in time to a certain time in the past, and you can be very clear about what is going to happen after that point in time. The problem is that we don't have future data for the present, so we can't figure out the position of the exact axis representing the direction. Of course, I still hope that some friends can figure out whether it is as I deduce, because I still can't understand the processing logic of that paragraph about historical data.
 
Liu Xin said:
Hello,is this also read H4 histroy data when running backtest?
Click to expand...
Hi Liu Xin, Bro May I have this EA Super Vijay v1.1.1 ?. It is not available anymore for download in the Thread. It was doing very well unfortunately, my computer crashed and I lost all except the statement on the terminal. Please post it or send it to my email or send a personal message. [email protected]
 
Godwin said:
I will do that when this version expires.
Click to expand...
Hello Godwin,
I've been following the thread here. I have to say that I really admire all the coders here in the forum and I give them high appreciation. I'm also testing the Xpert.
I don't know if this one has the forward history read or not, but I'm still convinced that this EA has potential. During testing on demo I had some losses on USD JPY within few days. Then I backtested the same period of a few days in the mt4 tester; the results were pretty much the same.
Please take a look
Only in the pair GBP USD missed some profit trades on the demo account. Here I suspect that the trades in the demo account were not opened because of the probable high spread (which would then later have led to winning according to the backtest...) So if the EA were a forward reader, then it would smooth the graph in this period in the backtest , or not ? I think everyone knows that the trades in the backtest are not exactly identical to those on the current account, because of spreads or cheating brokers or something else....
As another member posted in the thread, his account got crashed, using the oluka version. In my humble opinion this is due to the high number of max orders. The max orders must be limited, then it should work
For example when TP 100 and SL 50 , then max orders 25 are enough
With TPca 67 and SL ca 36, 9 max orders are enough. Then the losses would not be so big.
Also, a change in the code would also be useful for adding new orders when the first order is in profit or has already been closed in profit, and reducing the max orders when a trade is already in loss or has already been closed in loss. I don't know how to do that either, it's just a humble suggestion from me.....

So would it be possible for you to post the Oluka version, with the blue line moving, with available inputs for Max orders and spread settings in the EA, here?
 

Attachments

  • Xpert USD JPY backtest 9 max orders.png
    Xpert USD JPY backtest 9 max orders.png
    16.4 KB · Views: 244
  • Xpert USD JPY backtest 25 max orders.png
    Xpert USD JPY backtest 25 max orders.png
    16.6 KB · Views: 222
  • Xpert USD JPY backtest bericht 9 max orders.png
    Xpert USD JPY backtest bericht 9 max orders.png
    28.9 KB · Views: 195
  • Xpert USD JPY backtest bericht 25 max orders.png
    Xpert USD JPY backtest bericht 25 max orders.png
    35.6 KB · Views: 198
  • Xpert USD JPY demo account 9 max orders.png
    Xpert USD JPY demo account 9 max orders.png
    109.8 KB · Views: 249
Derling34 said:
This is my review for this thread:
Worthless history reading shit
Click to expand...
Hello ,
maybe you are right, but did you take a look at the screenshots i made ?
Well comparing the backtest on mt4 tester and the live results i made on demo for that period, they are pretty similar, or not ?
So where left the smoothing of the graf for that period in backtesting( when it wood be forward history reading) ? So i am not shure either, but will keeping running the EA for other 2-3 weeks and will see

Thanks for your reply
 
fomuth said:
Hello ,
maybe you are right, but did you take a look at the screenshots i made ?
Well comparing the backtest on mt4 tester and the live results i made on demo for that period, they are pretty similar, or not ?
So where left the smoothing of the graf for that period in backtesting( when it wood be forward history reading) ? So i am not shure either, but will keeping running the EA for other 2-3 weeks and will see

Thanks for your reply
Click to expand...

when you are backtesting look at that line . you see its go so far out of chart candles then expert selling and buying in that trend way .. its mean its reading forward history H4 .. and put the ea in real time with 30pip SL and 30 Pip Tp for 3 days then back and test that 3 days you see all back test and opening times are different .. you did not put the pictures of your back test details i mean treads times for opening and closing. cuz if you check with your forward pics it will be completely different ..
 
death_666 said:
when you are backtesting look at that line . you see its go so far out of chart candles then expert selling and buying in that trend way .. its mean its reading forward history H4 .. and put the ea in real time with 30pip SL and 30 Pip Tp for 3 days then back and test that 3 days you see all back test and opening times are different .. you did not put the pictures of your back test details i mean treads times for opening and closing. cuz if you check with your forward pics it will be completely different ..
Click to expand...
Thanks a lot for your detailed comments
 
Hamid Reza said:
This EA read history in 4H TF and used in lower timeframe then show great result but in the real open many orders in opposite trend, if your balance 1000$ and hit SL 50 pip in default setting means 70*5$=350$ ---> 35% loses of each SL hit.
you can't never backtest in 4H TF because the expert cannot use the data at the same time and take the position, for this reason the expert uses kernel32.dll to read 4H TF information before backtest to deceive you.

This Expert is SCAM
Click to expand...
Hello Hamid, Your analysis is perfect on xpert EA. I tried all combinations in the forward tests and results are just like you said. Hats off to you. Is there anyone here who got profitable results from this EA in forward tests ?.
 
Lipton said:
:)

I WISH YOU ALL HAPPY TRAIDING.

BEST
K.L.
Click to expand...
Hello Lipton, thanks a ton for modifying xpert with major indicators and importantly sharing with us. I put all of them on demo. To my surprise all of them opened trades. Let me see how it perform on forward test. As far as I know Xpert EA doing exceedingly doing well and miserably failed in forward test. Thanks again for your concern for others.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top