Suggestion My Holy Grail After 4 years of trading

[leo333]

bp => change your LookBack to 450.

regardless of AUDCHF, this is a problem EA wide. your logic has a flaw. it leaves trades unattended if it leaves the signal zone area.

this is not how people trade martingale in the real world. once the process starts, it needs to follow the sequence whether price is still in the signal zone or not.

right now, your EA only trades when price is in the signal zone. when price leaves the zone, it stops placing additional trades. THIS IS SUICIDE.

i recall you stating you don’t trade martingale. it is very obvious now because i am not getting through to you, and it doesn’t seem like you understand what i am talking about.

so with all of this aside, the solution i request is very simple but may be complicated for you to complete the task. once again, it is very simple.

once a trade starts, do not let EA stop trading until it completes the trade. it doesn’t matter if the price is not in the signal zone anymore at M15 checkpoint, signal zone is only necessary for assessing new trades and signals.

if it has to be an option, that is fine. but without it,
every EA you create that uses a grid-based martingale is doomed to meet it’s maker.

bp, are we on the same page now?

View attachment 118040

Dont change Lookback to 450!! Its your own fault.. Not from bp...

Like "Lookback" says. He looks back for Zones 450 Bars. So he will take a trade even its not in the Zone anymore. Change lookback closer to get new, actual Zones.

 

[Forex_Trader]

View attachment 118044
does anyone out there understand what i am trying to relay to bp2000? any support? bueller, bueller??

I understand what you mean. Very good point.

 

[Forex_Trader]

Dont change Lookback to 450!! Its your own fault.. Not from bp...

Like "Lookback" says. He looks back for Zones 450 Bars. So he will take a trade even its not in the Zone anymore. Change lookback closer to get new, actual Zones.

I dont think you understand his point.

Dont change Lookback to 450!! Its your own fault.. Not from bp...

Like "Lookback" says. He looks back for Zones 450 Bars. So he will take a trade even its not in the Zone anymore. Change lookback closer to get new, actual Zones.

Oh, so if the trend reverses and there is a opposite signal, what do you think will happend to your earlier trades? Do rmb that there is no SL for this EA.

 

[alij79]

Dont change Lookback to 450!! Its your own fault.. Not from bp...

Like "Lookback" says. He looks back for Zones 450 Bars. So he will take a trade even its not in the Zone anymore. Change lookback closer to get new, actual Zones.

yea he is changing loopback and blaming bp2000 lol

 

[alij79]

it’s not a LookBack issue.

any feedback from someone who understands the science of martingale?

i understand science but not ur matingale

 

[Forex_Trader]

yea he is changing loopback and blaming bp2000 lol

No no, its not what shane meant. You guys got the wrong understanding i guess.

 

[vuret]

[QUOTE = "s.shane, post: 403638, miembro: 59795"] no es un problema de LookBack.

¿Algún comentario de alguien que entienda la ciencia de la martingala? [/ QUOTE]


Te entiendo, no soy un experto en el mundo de Forex, pero sé cómo funciona la martingala y tienes algo de raza, no puedes dejar la operación abierta y sin control

 

[negin]

bp => change your LookBack to 450.

regardless of AUDCHF, this is a problem EA wide. your logic has a flaw. it leaves trades unattended if it leaves the signal zone area.

this is not how people trade martingale in the real world. once the process starts, it needs to follow the sequence whether price is still in the signal zone or not.

right now, your EA only trades when price is in the signal zone. when price leaves the zone, it stops placing additional trades. THIS IS SUICIDE.

i recall you stating you don’t trade martingale. it is very obvious now because i am not getting through to you, and it doesn’t seem like you understand what i am talking about.

so with all of this aside, the solution i request is very simple but may be complicated for you to complete the task. once again, it is very simple.

once a trade starts, do not let EA stop trading until it completes the trade. it doesn’t matter if the price is not in the signal zone anymore at M15 checkpoint, signal zone is only necessary for assessing new trades and signals.

if it has to be an option, that is fine. but without it,
every EA you create that uses a grid-based martingale is doomed to meet it’s maker.

bp, are we on the same page now?

View attachment 118040

Hi Shane ,

Yes you are right.At present the EA not doing any follow up for the trades that opened while price was in the zone and later it moved from the respected zone.

 

[username77]

View attachment 118047
神風

hope you are in demo.

 

[vitalii]

This is my review for this thread:
Лучшая стратегия.

 

[vitalii]

Подтверждение.

 

[kaido]

Подтверждение.

manual trading or EA?

 

[smad1]

Being Kind goes a long way, Good thread

 

[Forex_Trader]

This is my review for this thread:
Reliable and good

 

[Yoyo Man]

50lots is really really mad but worth it for a large account like yours

 

[elias mazariegos]

[QUOTE = "vitalii, publicación: 403684, miembro: 31954"] Подтверждение. [/ QUOTE]
could you share the settings you used please

 

[Soramasqus]

Great indie!

 

[Ivan96]

This is my review for this thread:
Bp Thanks so much from Colombia. your EA is perfect!!

 

[Zulkainain]

[QUOTE = "bp2000, jawatan: 403234, ahli: 43234"] Tolong bantu saya.
Saya mahu menambah Elliott Wave sebagai penapis.
Adakah ini Elliott Wave yang sah? Terima kasih
[ATTACH = penuh] 117909 [/ LAMPIRAN] [/ QUOTE]

 

[Zulkainain]

[QUOTE = "bp2000, jawatan: 403234, ahli: 43234"] Tolong bantu saya.
Saya mahu menambah Elliott Wave sebagai penapis.
Adakah ini Elliott Wave yang sah? Terima kasih