• Welcome back! Thank you for being a part of this Traders Community. Let's discuss and share :)
    Selamat datang kembali! Trimakasih telah menjadi bagian dari Komunitas Trader ini. Mari berdiskusi dan berbagi :)

New EA Auto Trading Portfolio (Free EA, No Expiration)

Reader mode
Hello!
Firstly I would like to thank the authors for the hard and nice job and for the EA.
I started testing on two different brokers.
The opening of transactions is different. I would like to hear the authors of what they can say about this .. Is it normal?
I hope this does not significantly affect the performance of the expert and I'm looking forward to the final version.
 

Attachments

  • ATP PROTOTYPE EURUSD H1.jpg
    ATP PROTOTYPE EURUSD H1.jpg
    149.3 KB · Views: 125
unreal-1980 said:
Hello!
Firstly I would like to thank the authors for the hard and nice job and for the EA.
I started testing on two different brokers.
The opening of transactions is different. I would like to hear the authors of what they can say about this .. Is it normal?
I hope this does not significantly affect the performance of the expert and I'm looking forward to the final version.
Click to expand...

I don't get it - whats different there? I see a sell in both MT4's.
 
unreal-1980 said:
Hello!
Firstly I would like to thank the authors for the hard and nice job and for the EA.
I started testing on two different brokers.
The opening of transactions is different. I would like to hear the authors of what they can say about this .. Is it normal?
I hope this does not significantly affect the performance of the expert and I'm looking forward to the final version.
Click to expand...
Hi unreal-1980

Thank you for your report

Please add these indicators to the second chart (below) :
1. Force Index, method:simple, period:18
2. Stochastic Oscillator, %K:22, %D:8, Slowing:2
3. Average True Range, period:8

Then please take a screenshot and upload it.
 
unreal-1980 said:
Hello!
Firstly I would like to thank the authors for the hard and nice job and for the EA.
I started testing on two different brokers.
The opening of transactions is different. I would like to hear the authors of what they can say about this .. Is it normal?
I hope this does not significantly affect the performance of the expert and I'm looking forward to the final version.
Click to expand...
I face same but I open different brokers different time 1day gab but we see different position and some time close her we don’t close in other ????
 
We have question for mr autotradingportfilo when I use the expert with more currencies like Eur/usd and gob/usd and aud/usd and eur/chf the expert he trderd saparet or bascket on go big Frieda won ?
 
alaakenanah said:
I face same but I open different brokers different time 1day gab but we see different position and some time close her we don’t close in other ????
Click to expand...
Thanks for your reply.
I believe that nothing needs to be closed with hands because we do not know where the position is "correct" of these two differences .. the expert should close himself otherwise the idea of the ATP strategy is violated
 
Hi unreal-1980 thank you for the picture,

Could you please check on the second chart whether the ATR on the opening candle was rising or not?

Because from what I can see here, the ATR on the first chart was slightly rising, while in the second chart was falling. I maybe wrong because I can't see it clearly.
 
autotradingportfolio said:
Hi unreal-1980 thank you for the picture,

Could you please check on the second chart whether the ATR on the opening candle was rising or not?

Because from what I can see here, the ATR on the first chart was slightly rising, while in the second chart was falling. I maybe wrong because I can't see it clearly.
Click to expand...

Hi ^)
That's what I get..same subwindows and Bars. It's ok for you now?
 

Attachments

  • ATP PROTOTYPE 3 EURUSD H1.png
    ATP PROTOTYPE 3 EURUSD H1.png
    273.9 KB · Views: 110
Last edited:
No, there's a trade on July 2, and it's still open, the EA won't open additional trades using that strategy (the ea itself is portfolio of various strategies), let's call it strategy number 9.

Seems like the ATR is the culprit, the EA should open a position when ATR rises, Force Index cross the zero line upward and Stochastic line is lower than signal line. The ATR angle is very vague. Seems like it slightly rise on the first chart and slightly fall on the second chart. Different broker data seems to produce different ATR angle.

We may exclude ATR based strategy on the next version.
 
autotradingportfolio said:
No, there's a trade on July 2, and it's still open, the EA won't open additional trades using that strategy (the ea itself is portfolio of various strategies), let's call it strategy number 9.

Seems like the ATR is the culprit, the EA should open a position when ATR rises, Force Index cross the zero line upward and Stochastic line is lower than signal line. The ATR angle is very vague. Seems like it slightly rise on the first chart and slightly fall on the second chart. Different broker data seems to produce different ATR angle.

We may exclude ATR based strategy on the next version.
Click to expand...
Do you think the big diffrent in the performance between the brokers and the same broker the back test ok it seems the forwored test ok
 
autotradingportfolio said:
No, there's a trade on July 2, and it's still open, the EA won't open additional trades using that strategy (the ea itself is portfolio of various strategies), let's call it strategy number 9.

Seems like the ATR is the culprit, the EA should open a position when ATR rises, Force Index cross the zero line upward and Stochastic line is lower than signal line. The ATR angle is very vague. Seems like it slightly rise on the first chart and slightly fall on the second chart. Different broker data seems to produce different ATR angle.

We may exclude ATR based strategy on the next version.
Click to expand...

Thanks for your respond and explaining.
In the previous pictures it was not visible .. Now when I increased the scaling on the chart, it is clear that ATR touches the border of FI. Maybe when that bar was opened (screen below) at the time there was the same situation as I indicated in the picture, and the sell order was activated by this broker, and on the second one there is nothing. It's strange that in my previous pictures it's not visible ...seems ATR or FI (or both of them) rescaling with chart.. Did you mean it?
 

Attachments

  • ATP PROTOTYPE 4 EURUSD H1.png
    ATP PROTOTYPE 4 EURUSD H1.png
    161.6 KB · Views: 104
Last edited:
unreal-1980 said:
Thanks for your respond and explaining.
In the previous pictures it was not visible .. Now when I increased the scaling on the chart, it is clear that ATR touches the border of FI. Maybe when that bar was opened (screen below) at the time there was the same situation as I indicated in the picture, and the sell order was activated by this broker, and on the second one there is nothing. It's strange that in my previous pictures it's not visible ...seems ATR or FI (or both of them) rescaling with chart.. Did you mean it?
Click to expand...
Oops.. my mistake, I didn't realize it was a sell, could you please do one more favor to me.

On that scale, please add zero line to the force index indicator?
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top