1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Saat ini forum sudah dibuka untuk umum, namun masih tetap dalam tahap pengujian. Hampir semua aktivitas dalam forum ini memiliki nilai Credit atau Equity. Nantinya, Credit atau Equity yang dikumpulkan akan dapat digunakan untuk berbagai tujuan, misalnya untuk biaya pemesanan EA, sewa VPS, untuk belanja di store (jika ada), beli EA (jika ada), dan untuk membayar biaya keanggotaan SoeHoe Markets.
    Dismiss Notice
  3. Hi Guest, non-user hanya bisa melihat 5 halaman per hari. Mengapa tidak mendaftar saja jadi user? Gratis koq, silakan klik register, hanya 30 detik :)

    Dismiss Notice

New EA Auto Trading Portfolio (Free EA, No Expiration)

Discussion in 'Expert Advisor atau Robot Forex' started by autotradingportfolio, 05 Jun 2018.

  1. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hi unreal-1980unreal-1980 thank you for the picture,

    Could you please check on the second chart whether the ATR on the opening candle was rising or not?

    Because from what I can see here, the ATR on the first chart was slightly rising, while in the second chart was falling. I maybe wrong because I can't see it clearly.
     
  2. unreal-1980

    unreal-1980 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hi ^)
    That's what I get..same subwindows and Bars. It's ok for you now?
     

    Attached Files:

    Last edited: 06 Jul 2018
  3. unreal-1980

    unreal-1980 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Would like to ask more .. Have you ever seen this from your tests?
     
    Last edited: 06 Jul 2018
  4. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    No, there's a trade on July 2, and it's still open, the EA won't open additional trades using that strategy (the ea itself is portfolio of various strategies), let's call it strategy number 9.

    Seems like the ATR is the culprit, the EA should open a position when ATR rises, Force Index cross the zero line upward and Stochastic line is lower than signal line. The ATR angle is very vague. Seems like it slightly rise on the first chart and slightly fall on the second chart. Different broker data seems to produce different ATR angle.

    We may exclude ATR based strategy on the next version.
     
    • Like Like x 1
  5. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Do you think the big diffrent in the performance between the brokers and the same broker the back test ok it seems the forwored test ok
     
  6. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    No I don't think so, the EA only use standard metatrader indicators, so I think most of trades will be similar. However we still need more data to collect.
     
  7. unreal-1980

    unreal-1980 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Thanks for your respond and explaining.
    In the previous pictures it was not visible .. Now when I increased the scaling on the chart, it is clear that ATR touches the border of FI. Maybe when that bar was opened (screen below) at the time there was the same situation as I indicated in the picture, and the sell order was activated by this broker, and on the second one there is nothing. It's strange that in my previous pictures it's not visible ...seems ATR or FI (or both of them) rescaling with chart.. Did you mean it?
     

    Attached Files:

    Last edited: 07 Jul 2018
  8. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Oops.. my mistake, I didn't realize it was a sell, could you please do one more favor to me.

    On that scale, please add zero line to the force index indicator?
     
    • Like Like x 1
  9. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    I mean, please make the zero line on the force index visible.
     
  10. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    we hope no different between the back test and forward test ?
     
  11. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    I test for 2 days on EUR/USD with 2 different brokers up to now we get 2 different trades between the brokers :
    Broker No 1/ 4 buy and 3 sell (closed 1 buy and still open 3 buy and 3 sell )
    broker No 2 /3 buy and 2 sell ( closed 2 buy and still open 1 buy and 2 sell )
    on Back test :
    Broker No 1 / Open 1 sell
    broker No 2 / Open 3 buy and 2 sell
     
  12. unreal-1980

    unreal-1980 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Ok :) at your request..Forex index zero line (green color)
     

    Attached Files:

  13. natapat

    natapat New Member

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Nice result in bt @M15
     
  14. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Thank you,

    Because it's a sell, the rules would be:
    1. Force Index crosses the zero line downward
    2. Stochastic line is higher than the Signal line
    3. ATR rises

    On the first chart we can see that Force Index crossed the zero line downward just a little bit, there's a very tiny Force Index line on the previous candle, (because EA open a position on bar opening it will scan the condition of the previous candle)

    And on the second chart we can see that Force Index line didn't cross the zero line, we can say it's juts equal to zero line.

    So we can conclude that different price data feed produce different indicators value, that's why sometimes some commercial EA has different result between different brokers.

    SS 07072018.png
    We're actually about to release the USDCAD version today, but it's seems it'll be postponed until the problem is resolved.

    Once again thank you for reporting the error, it's very useful.
     
    Last edited: 08 Jul 2018
    • Like Like x 1
  15. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hi alaakenanah,

    Thank you for reporting,

    Could you please inform the magic numbers of the trades? We'll need to identify which strategy is used.

    Best regards.
     
  16. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point

    Broker No 1
    Buy magic number 500016
    Buy magic number 500013
    Buy magic number 500007
    Buy magic number 500003 closed
    Sell magic number 500018
    Sell magic number 500010
    Sell magic number 500008

    Broker No 2
    Buy magic number 500012
    Buy magic number 500013 closed
    Buy magic number 500007 closed
    Sell magic number 500010
    Sell magic number 500008

    Thx
     
  17. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    we hope the strategy not main in the performance special to close postilion please advise ?

    from the above what do you think broker no 1 or broker no 2 ? its ok or fit with your expert
     
  18. unreal-1980

    unreal-1980 Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Hi !
    What exactly updated in this version? TF, pairs, etc..?
    what's the difference between previous versions and why mr.autotradingportfolio didn’t share it before?
    and for each pair there is a separate bot, but what is this?
     
    Last edited: 08 Jul 2018
  19. alaakenanah

    alaakenanah Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
     
  20. autotradingportfolio

    autotradingportfolio Active Member Credit Hunter

    Equity
    Credit
    Ref Point
    Man.. do you want to deceive the others with the fake EA :mad::mad:?

    You should be banned from this forum:mad:

    If you have a good EA, It'd be better if you start your own thread.
     
    Last edited: 08 Jul 2018
    • Like Like x 4

Share This Page